Visualising China
Updates from Historical Photographs of China: http://hpcbristol.net
Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
  • People
  • Useful Links
← New year … new platform: introducing www.hpcbristol.net
The Kodak comes to Peking →

Is it a mouse, is it a cat?

Posted on January 18, 2017 by Robert Bickers
Gerald and Donald Johns wearing fancy dress, Dalian. Thomas Johns Collection Jo01-22 © 2011 Jeremy Rowett Johns.

Gerald and Donald Johns wearing fancy dress, Dalian. Thomas Johns Collection Jo01-22 © 2011 Jeremy Rowett Johns.

It’s a cat, Felix the Cat to be precise. To continue my discussion about dates, identifications and being corrected, I can provide a little demonstration of the power of crowd-sourcing data-annotation. Well, that is the technical term. In practical terms, an environmental historian of China queried a January 1928 date we had attributed to the photograph below, because in the caption we had said the children were holding a Mickey Mouse toy. But the might mouse, he pointed out, did not debut until 1928. It was unlikely that he had made his way across the Pacific quite so rapidly. Why not check the accuracy of the date, an art-historian with an expertise in the Ming suggested. We went back to the album page.

We checked the pencilled and overwritten date, which as you can see (perhaps) really is very unclear. But we revised our reading to January 1929.

screen-shot-2017-01-18-at-08-03-44

Ah, said the art historian, having looked again more closely, but that is not Mickey Mouse. It is the trickster cat, Felix. And of course it is. Felix the Cat made his debut in a 1919 animation, and even Dalian (Dairen, Dalny) would have known of him by 1928, or 1929. He was a regular feature on Chinese movie programmes by 1924. Here is from the South China Morning Post in January that year.

Felix revolts

Felix the catSo hello there, Felix. We have learned a great deal over ten years of looking at China through these photographs. Buildings, streets, bridges, shops have become familiar (for there is much repetition and predicability in the would be photographer’s gaze). We do as much research as is sensible with each photographer in order to provide a reasonable minimum of metadata to allow images to be found through searches. But sometimes, in fact probably often, we have missed the feline obvious, not recognised the building, not identified the individual, misunderstood the context. Do let us have your suggestions. They are not always right, but more often than not they are, as the combined expertise of our community of users far exceeds our own.

Felix the Cat joins our roster of notable and influential individuals in Historical Photographs of China, joining Chiang Kai-shek, Rabindranath Tagore, Sir Robert Hart and Song Qingling.

 

This entry was posted in Image Annotation and tagged children, Dairen, metadata, user engagement. Bookmark the permalink.
← New year … new platform: introducing www.hpcbristol.net
The Kodak comes to Peking →
  • Recent Posts

    • Need and opportunity: the new HPC website
    • Everything’s changed, but everything’s still the same: HPC update
    • Location/Dislocation – Admiral Keppel, the Chinese Buddha at Sandringham and three key photographs
    • The Forbidden City at War: Images of the Wartime Evacuation of the Imperial Art Collections
    • A name, a photograph, and a history of global connections
    • ‘Normal’ Lives Led in Abnormal Conditions
    • Charles Frederick Moore’s photographs of the ruins of the European-style palaces (西洋楼) at the Yuanmingyuan (圆明园)
    • Pieces of China in Bristol – cataloguing Historical Photographs of China material
    • A disturbing intimacy: The Private Papers of C. C. A. Kirke
    • Jamie Carstairs on Remembering John Thomson in Edinburgh
    • Guest blog: Nadine Attewell on Refocusing the Gaze: Leisure, Power, and Women’s Work in Interwar Hong Kong
    • HPC: A Change of Pace
    • Guest blog: Claire Lowrie on ‘Travelling Servants and Moving Images: A Photographic History of Chinese Domestic Workers’
    • Guest blog: The Cercle Sportif Français: Elite cosmopolitanism in Shanghai’s Former French Concession.
    • Black and white Hong Kong transformed by ‘OldHKinColour’
  • Categories

  • Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • Bristol Blogs
  • Recent Tweets

    Tweets by vischina

Visualising China
Proudly powered by WordPress.
Subscribe

Subscribe By Email

Get every new post delivered right to your inbox.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.